If she managed to stay asleep through all this, she was going to wake up with her panties covered in dried cum, and that was fine with me: I just desperately needed to get off. Just as well, since the temptation to push Susie’s panties to the size and fuck the hell out of her was powerfully strong. Amateur porn “Maybe if you did, Scott would let me fuck Susie. I took one hand off of Susie’s hip, reached to the side, and found one of Cathy’s breasts. “Scott!”
“I didn’t hear any–”
“I was just getting a glass of water. Through my boxers and her panties, of course, but it still felt good. “Listen.”
Cathy and Carl’s bed was creaking softly – but more significantly, we could hear… Touching me very gently as I fucked her sister, Cathy slowly moved her hand down to my waist, to my ass, and finally rested one finger on my anus, holding it in place as I thrusted. “Last chance,” she said to Susie. “You’re acting so weird tonight I think you’d actually do it,” Susie said. And as I closed my hand around my wife’s breast, I could still remember the feel of Cathy’s. “Shhh,” said whispered. She straddled me and then very carefully, because we could barely see one another, lowered her wet pussy onto my cock.
